SOTM #25 [July] [Poll] - Heat 2

[uekipheonix]

Theme : Black and White

• Vote for the best sig.
• No self votes and all votes are public.
• All sigs are anonymous until winers are decided.
• So it is strictly forbidden to reveal the names of contestants and heir work.

may the force be with you all

click ---> here for the other heat.

[Rynn]

Voted for B3.Not many effects but the details look clean and nice.

Good luck,everyone! ^^

[Draak]

b2 got my vote due to the eye candy

[xSora]

B3 GMV. Same reasons with Rynn :)

[Muse]

It wasn't easy voting in this heat. There were 4 awesome sigs!

Voted for B3 because it's very striking and i really like that about it, the render pops out boldly from the stark white background. And love the effects in their too. I think I've to realize that i like sigs with less eye candy after all - the less c4d it has the more i like it. Just my personal preference though ^^

Goodluck!

[RebbieChan]

I like 1 the best, but it didn't work for being black and white.
I voted for 3 because it was the only one that I could see in one of the other non black and white contests because the black and white really worked for it.

[Ruby]

voted for B4

[Tessa-chan]

So, yeah, some humble opinions here :P .

#1 It's the most interesting out of the 4 [for me enlist], but I bet the colored version looks way better. The text is hard to read and overall the signature is too white. Still voted for it because of the interesting concept.

#2 Again a signature that probably looks better with colors. The concept overall is nicely done thought I hate the text: the way it's placed, font used and especially: what it says. Why "Naruto Uzumaki"? This isn't a claimed character request, you could have go with so many more fitting choices. Be a little creative next time and make your sig more interesting for the viewer. For me, this one just looks empty. First impression: wow, looks coll. Second impression: so, that's it?

#3 Very nice sig! I was going for this one before deciding to give originality some more points and vote for the first one. Effects are nicely done, the text looks a little cut out, but I appreciate the fact that you didn't resume only to the character's name and added a little more feeling to your sig. I also like the fact that you didn't filled the sig with effects. It's looks so much better like this. Anyway, even from the votes you can tel this is a winning signature. See you in the finals. Probably there I'll give you my vote, thought there are some signatures I like from the other heat as well, but I'm not 100% they're getting to the finals yet. About yours, I'm pretty sure :P .
P.S.: add a border to it, damn it XD.

#4 The render looks pixelated, like you forgot to keep shift on when you shrunk it. The black is overleveled and if you were going to go for the pure black and white effect you should have leveled more. Leaving gray tons on the sig just makes it look overleveld. Text is not really well placed, is hard to read and doesn't blend so much with the rest of the sig. I did like the ideea and the image you used.

Well, good luck to all participants :) .

[iLium]

I voted for # 3 because the black and white concept was done the best.
#4 hasn't got a very sharp render
While #2 has a nice concept.. the background didn't work for me.. too chaotic and it didn't blend well..
#1 one is good, but it looks like it was better if done in colour :)

So..
Good luck to everyone :D

[Mykka]

I went for the B3 'cause well.......mostly the others dont fit the b&w theme :/ I am sorry....I probably think that 'cause the eyes are used to some color and such, so yeah, maybe that affected a lot :)
though like Tessa said.....B3 could have a border :3